Bing Search

Big Miracle

:

Critics' Reviews

Our critic says...
Metascore
®
61
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
Cast Saves Whales, 'Big Miracle'
Glenn Kenny, Special to MSN Movies

"Everybody loves whales," John Krasinski enthuses early on in this movie. He seems to have a point, if the ever-burgeoning name cast of "Big Miracle" is any indication. That's not to say that the movie, directed by Ken Kwapis and based on a real-life late '80s incident involving a trio of lovable swimming mammals trapped under ice in coldest upper Alaska, is packed with superstars (if that category even exists in the cinema arts anymore.) But it serves up a rather uncannily steady parade of recognizable performers in almost comically rapid succession: Krasinski, Drew Barrymore, Kathy Baker, Ted Danson, Kristen Bell, Stephen Root, Vinessa Shaw, Dermot Mulroney ... and it just goes on. About midway through the picture, a bearded guy from Minneapolis turns up in the arctic wilderness, doing something like a Bob and Doug MacKenzie schtick (Minneapolis being reasonably close to Canada, one guesses), and seeing him, you may ask yourself, "Is that James LeGros?" It is.

Search: More on Drew Barrymore | More on Greenpeace

This array of talent portrays an array of characters of disparate backgrounds and interests who somehow form a family ... OK, an alliance, to save, you know, the whales, who are nicknamed Fred, Wilma and Bam-Bam. ("Why Bam-Bam and not Pebbles?" you may ask. It is explained, if you need it to be.) Krasinski's an amiable but ambitious TV news reporter who unearths the story, Barrymore's the Greenpeace activist who's also his ex, Danson's an oilman in search of positive publicity, Bell's another ambitious TV reporter trying to scoop smarmy rival John Michael Higgins (did I mention John Michael Higgins is in this?), and Root is the governor. As the story goes national and attracts massive media attention, forcing a slight lifestyle change within the Inupiat Eskimo tribe that constitutes the indigenous population of the area, politics rears its interesting head, and the story attracts attention from not just Ronald Reagan, but the Soviets, as a Russian vessel could be the only hope for breaking through the ice that's holding the whales captive.

Sounds like a perfect vehicle for unremitting schmaltz, and the movie certainly has its fair share of that. However, it also has a more-than-fair amount of wry humor, droll political observation if not actual satire, and nicely understated emotional content in the romance department. The role of the almost overearnest environmental crusader is well-nigh perfect for Barrymore, whose prominent de-glamming here is explained in a throwaway line in which her character sneers about cosmetics being tested on animals.

This detail is in fact rather emblematic of the way "Big Miracle" brings unusual nuance to a hoary heartstring-tugging saga, and thus renders it several notches above average in its genre. And it's also got the aforementioned whales, rendered mostly via what look like highly expert special effects. They're plaintive, alert and largely adorable, and the underwater sequences pack a cavernous lyricism that's uncommon in most entertainments of this sort. If this movie already looks like your kind of thing, you won't be disappointed. If you think it's absolutely not your kind of thing, you might be surprised.

Glenn Kenny is chief film critic for MSN Movies. He was the chief film critic for Premiere magazine from 1998 to 2007. He contributes to various publications and websites, and blogs at http://somecamerunning.typepad.com. He lives in Brooklyn.

For more movie news, follow MSN Movies on Facebook and Twitter.

"Everybody loves whales," John Krasinski enthuses early on in this movie. He seems to have a point, if the ever-burgeoning name cast of "Big Miracle" is any indication. That's not to say that the movie, directed by Ken Kwapis and based on a real-life late '80s incident involving a trio of lovable swimming mammals trapped under ice in coldest upper Alaska, is packed with superstars (if that category even exists in the cinema arts anymore.) But it serves up a rather uncannily steady parade of recognizable performers in almost comically rapid succession: Krasinski, Drew Barrymore, Kathy Baker, Ted Danson, Kristen Bell, Stephen Root, Vinessa Shaw, Dermot Mulroney ... and it just goes on. About midway through the picture, a bearded guy from Minneapolis turns up in the arctic wilderness, doing something like a Bob and Doug MacKenzie schtick (Minneapolis being reasonably close to Canada, one guesses), and seeing him, you may ask yourself, "Is that James LeGros?" It is.

Search: More on Drew Barrymore | More on Greenpeace

This array of talent portrays an array of characters of disparate backgrounds and interests who somehow form a family ... OK, an alliance, to save, you know, the whales, who are nicknamed Fred, Wilma and Bam-Bam. ("Why Bam-Bam and not Pebbles?" you may ask. It is explained, if you need it to be.) Krasinski's an amiable but ambitious TV news reporter who unearths the story, Barrymore's the Greenpeace activist who's also his ex, Danson's an oilman in search of positive publicity, Bell's another ambitious TV reporter trying to scoop smarmy rival John Michael Higgins (did I mention John Michael Higgins is in this?), and Root is the governor. As the story goes national and attracts massive media attention, forcing a slight lifestyle change within the Inupiat Eskimo tribe that constitutes the indigenous population of the area, politics rears its interesting head, and the story attracts attention from not just Ronald Reagan, but the Soviets, as a Russian vessel could be the only hope for breaking through the ice that's holding the whales captive.

Sounds like a perfect vehicle for unremitting schmaltz, and the movie certainly has its fair share of that. However, it also has a more-than-fair amount of wry humor, droll political observation if not actual satire, and nicely understated emotional content in the romance department. The role of the almost overearnest environmental crusader is well-nigh perfect for Barrymore, whose prominent de-glamming here is explained in a throwaway line in which her character sneers about cosmetics being tested on animals.

This detail is in fact rather emblematic of the way "Big Miracle" brings unusual nuance to a hoary heartstring-tugging saga, and thus renders it several notches above average in its genre. And it's also got the aforementioned whales, rendered mostly via what look like highly expert special effects. They're plaintive, alert and largely adorable, and the underwater sequences pack a cavernous lyricism that's uncommon in most entertainments of this sort. If this movie already looks like your kind of thing, you won't be disappointed. If you think it's absolutely not your kind of thing, you might be surprised.

Glenn Kenny is chief film critic for MSN Movies. He was the chief film critic for Premiere magazine from 1998 to 2007. He contributes to various publications and websites, and blogs at http://somecamerunning.typepad.com. He lives in Brooklyn.

For more movie news, follow MSN Movies on Facebook and Twitter.

75
SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE: Mick LaSalle

Big Miracle is not the most sophisticated adventure film, but compared with most family movies, it's practically something out of Noel Coward.

Read Full Review »
75
ST. LOUIS POST-DISPATCH: Joe Williams

Rounded, redemptive and refreshingly free of cynicism.

Read Full Review »
75
CHICAGO TRIBUNE: Michael Phillips

Big Miracle tells its sort-of-true version of events in a democratic and humane fashion, by way of a rangy, lively group of competing interests who actually do on occasion act like real people.

Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Janice Page

It needs only to entertain. And that it does thoroughly, leaving us both charmed and enriched without feeling very preached at. Praise be.

Read Full Review »
75
NPR: Ella Taylor

Big Miracle is a family movie fitted with the usual appeals to multiple audiences, and though tots, teens and younger parents might find the action a little slow until the rescue pressure builds, the grandparents will enjoy it as a trip down media memory lane.

Read Full Review »
70
The New York Times: Rachel Saltz

Big Miracle gets off to a shaky start, but once revved up, it becomes an involving work-against-the-clock-and-the-odds action movie.

Read Full Review »
70
Variety: Justin Chang

This family-friendly outing captures the story's human snowball effect with a measure of sly, satirical wit, if also an excess of boilerplate subplots and jokey '80s details.

Read Full Review »
63
Washington Post: 

As the minutes tick down, the sentimentality picks up. But chalk that up to the enigmatic creatures, which grab hold of human hearts no matter one's politics or affiliations. Whales just have a way of bringing people together.

Read Full Review »
60
NEW YORK DAILY NEWS: Joe Neumaier

The genuinely sweet nature of this sometimes clunky movie is mixed with a little sass, and wins you over.

Read Full Review »
58
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman

Big Miracle is harmless enough, but what's annoying about it is its aura of fake activism. The movie doesn't seem to get that it's exactly when the news media began to devote more time to subjects like whales that it started to turn into news not for activists but for couch potatoes.

Read Full Review »
See all Big Miracle reviews at metacritic.com »
showtimes & tickets
Search by location, title, or genre:
upcoming movies on
featured video